POL 358: Strategy, War, and Politics

Preliminary Battle Plan, rev. 2011-01-28; Total pages: 2155

Prof. Alex Montgomery-Amo

ahm@reed.edu

(503) 517-7395




Class

Office



TuTh 02:40-04:00 PM

TuTh 4:00-5:30 PM or by appointment
Vollum 118

Vollum 241
https://moodle.reed.edu/course/view.php?id=841

http://www.reed.edu/~ahm/



Course Description and Goals

This course examines contemporary problems of war and peace from a historical and theoretical perspective. What were the causes of war in the past and what can we learn from that experience? What strategies do actors in the international system use to employ force, and how have they changed in the nuclear age? What are the current problems facing decisionmakers today? The course begins with a review of political, psychological, organizational, cultural, and economic theories of the causes of war, then uses these theories to examine the origins and character of both historical and contemporary conflicts, including the First and Second World Wars and the Iraq War. It continues by examining the effects on conflict of the nuclear revolution. The course concludes by examining the major contemporary threats to national and international security that may be faced in the coming decade.

Students will learn to perform basic research and analysis through writing and thinking about conflict from multiple different perspectives. Readings are drawn from historic and contemporary scholars of strategy, war, and politics, cover a wide variety of issues, and are presented in context with historical and contemporary events. Assignments are a mixture of analysis, research, and experiential learning.

Requirements

Class Participation

Students are required to actively participate in the class; they will have the opportunity to do so both during and outside of classroom hours. Beginning the third week of class, each student will be assigned to three days during the semester in which they will author a short reaction memo (300-400 words) expressing an opinion about that day’s readings. These are NOT summaries; rather, they should attempt to agree or disagree with or compare and contrast the readings. This should be posted in the forums on the course website by 8 PM the day before the readings are to be discussed. ALL students are required to read the memos and be prepared to respond to them the next day in class. Students are encouraged to respond to the postings online as part of their participation. Students that miss class for whatever reason may make up the class by posting a memo to the course website for the day they missed, demonstrating that they did, in fact, do all the reading, but were desperately trapped under something heavy and thus could not make it.

Readings

Readings for the course are drawn from books available at the bookstore as well as E-Readings, which can be downloaded off the course website. Readings marked “Cases” are required, but should be read after any more theoretical articles. Readings marked “Further” are other relevant articles; they are not required for class. Students who have a particular interest in the topics in question are encouraged to read these articles and to incorporate them into their assignments. I encourage all students to use EndNote to download the class readings, take notes, and use for citing works in their papers. CUS has a page on Installing EndNote at Reed as well as a Basic Usage Guide online. However, laptops are not permitted in class unless you are taking notes and are willing to post those notes at the end of each class to the Moodle site.

Three books are for sale at the bookstore and are also on reserve at the library; Note that either the (black) 2002 second edition, the (red) 2005 updated second edition of Betts are fine. The relevant part (that is, all of it minus the initial commentary) of The Art of War is available on E-Readings as well, so purchasing the book is recommended, not required. Finally, those who are generally interested in the study of war classics may wish to purchase a copy of Clausewitz; make sure that you get the version edited by Michael Howard and Peter Paret, not the bowdlerized version by Anatol Rapoport.

Required

  • Richard K. Betts, editor (2002) Conflict after the Cold War: Arguments on Causes of War and Peace.  2nd edition. New York, NY: Longman <http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/46319630>, ISBN 0321081706
  • Robert J. Art and Kenneth N. Waltz, editors (2004) The Use of Force: Military Power and International Politics.  6th edition. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield <http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/52039593>, ISBN 0742525570

Recommended

Optional

  • Carl von Clausewitz; Michael Eliot Howard and Peter Paret, editors (1976) On War.  Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press <http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/71729075>, ISBN 0691056579

Course Website

Frequent reading of the course website will be helpful for success in the class. Discussion and collaboration with your peers is available to you through the website as well as in class; supplemental and core readings will be made available there; and assignments will be turned in electronically using the site.

Assignments and Quals

There are two formal assignments for this course. More details regarding the assignments will be available later. If you intend to qual in this course, you must let me know the first day. In general, I look for four things in an essay: A clear argument in the introductory paragraph, an explanation of the theories that you will be using, an illustration of your argument with direct examples, and a conclusion that discusses the implications of your findings. Note that word counts include your bibliography.

Citation and Plagiarism

A major goal of this course is to encourage good reading, research, and citation habits. Good research requires good documentation of sources and the ability to put one’s own analysis and thoughts into a paper rather than relying on others. When in doubt as to whether you should cite something, always do it. Citations are required for ideas as well as facts, and are imperative even if you are not directly quoting authors. Make sure that you provide as specific a citation as possible; if an author discusses an idea in one section or one page, cite the specific section or page instead of the full article or book. I usually recommend that students use in-text author-date citation with full Chicago Manual of Style citations; see their Citation Quick Guide: <http://www.chicagomanualofstyle.org/tools˙citationguide.html>.

However, style is less important than the cites being present. If you use an idea or a fact without attribution, you are plagiarizing someone else’s work. Plagiarism and cheating are violations of academic integrity and thus violations of Reed’s Honor Principle. As specified by Reed’s academic conduct policy, such violations will result in disciplinary actions, including suspension or permanent dismissal from the College. Plagiarism is submitting a piece of work which in part or in whole is not entirely the student’s own work without attributing those same portions to their correct source. For examples of plagiarism and how to avoid it, see <http://www.csub.edu/ssric-trd/howto/plagiarism.htm> For more information on Reed’s policies see: <http://www.reed.edu/academic/gbook/comm˙pol/acad˙conduct.html>.

Plagiarism often comes as the result of a student being up against a deadline without being able to meet it. If you are having trouble meeting a deadline for whatever reason, please contact me. Because every assignment is a paper that will be handed out well in advance, I have no problem giving extensions. It is always better to ask for more time than to plagiarize.

Accommodations

If you’d like to request academic accommodations due to a disability, please contact Learning Resources Director Heather Stout, Dorothy Johansen House, 503-517-7921, stouth@reed.edu. If you have a letter from Student Services, please let me know so we can discuss those accommodations.

1-Feb: 01.1. Introduction (26 Pages)

3-Feb: 01.2. Is War Inevitable? (56 Pages)

Part I: The Causes of War: WWI and Iraq

8-Feb: 02.1. History: World War I and Iraq (154 Pages)

Further

10-Feb: 02.2. Grand Theories of War (112 Pages)

Further

15-Feb: 03.1. International Politics-Power Balancing (83 Pages)

Cases

Further

17-Feb: 03.2. International Politics-Power Transitions (80 Pages)

Cases

Further

22-Feb: 04.1. International Politics-Money (100 Pages)

Cases

Further

24-Feb: 04.2. International Politics-Technology (110 Pages)

Cases

1-Mar: 05.1. Domestic Politics (95 Pages)

Cases

Further

3-Mar: 05.2. Organizations (115 Pages)

Cases

8-Mar: 06.1. Culture (122 Pages)

Cases

Further

10-Mar: 06.2. Psychology (87 Pages)

Cases

Further

15-Mar: 07.1. No Class

17-Mar: 07.2. No Class

22-Mar: 08.1. Spring Break

24-Mar: 08.2. Spring Break

Part II: From WWII to Nuclear Weapons

29-Mar: 09.1. Deterrence (104 Pages)

Cases

Further

31-Mar: 09.2. Compellence (90 Pages)

Cases

Further

5-Apr: 10.1. Nuclear Diplomacy (92 Pages)

Further

7-Apr: 10.2. Nuclear Defense (78 Pages)

Further

Part III: Contemporary Problems

12-Apr: 11.1. Rogue States (71 Pages)

Further

14-Apr: 11.2. Terrorism (87 Pages)

19-Apr: 12.1. Insurgencies (97 Pages)

Further

21-Apr: 12.2. Ethnic Conflict (87 Pages)

Further

26-Apr: 13.1. Grand Strategy (110 Pages)

Further

28-Apr: 13.2. US Strategy (72 Pages)

3-May: 14.1. Future Causes (77 Pages)

5-May: 14.2. Future of War (63 Pages)

Further